ERA, Shell Bicker Over Spills Investigation Reports

Environmental Rights Action/Friends of the Earth, Nigeria and Shell Petroleum Development Company have disagreed on spills investigation process in Bayelsa.
ERA/FoEN, an environment focused non-governmental organisation has accused SPDC of withholding Joint Investigation Visit reports of oil spill incidents traced to equipment failure to evade payment of compensation and promptly report sabotage induced spills.

The NGO explained that the oil firm had been engaging in the act of denying host communities in the Niger Delta access to JIV reports indicting the company over oil spill incidents.

The group, in a statement issued by Mr. Alagoa Morris, Head of Field Operation of ERA/FoEN in Yenagoa, also accused Shell of deploying security operatives to intimidate the communities and deny them of vital JIV reports.

It listed Ikarama and Biseni communities of Bayelsa State and Joinkrama 4, and Edagberi/Betterland communities in Rivers as some of the communities the company had denied JIV Reports.

It said, “SPDC often clandestinely denies the communities of the JIV reports; many of which are equipment failure-related oil spills. Shell has continued to deny the people of JK4 ,Ikarama and Biseni JIV reports craftily and, this is unacceptable.

“They withhold such reports from the communities and fail to post most of such incidents on the company’s spill incident website; the particular spill incident numbers are often quoted when giving out clean-up contracts.

“One such incident number is 900866 and relates to a 2012 spill which occurred at Shell’s Okordia Manifold at Ikarama which is conspicuously missing in SPDC’s website.

“After signing the JIV, Shell refused to give out the community copy on the pretext that they need to photocopy the report,on the way they forced down the community representatives from the vehicle and sped off .”

ERA/FoEN insisted it was the right of communities to have JIV reports signed by them and other stakeholders, stressing it was wrong for Shell to withhold the report which was supposed to form part of community records.

ERA/FoEN said that Shell underestimated spilled crude volume during JIVs of equipment failure related spills but inflated the quantity of spilled oil when it was attributed to oil theft.

Head of Medial Relations in SPDC, Mr. Precious Okolobo, in a reaction, said the oil firm conducts Joint Investigation Visits of spill sites in line with government regulations.

Okolobo explained that whenever a spill occurs, efforts are made to contain the spill, with access to the spill site usually a critical factor in shaping the response.

According to him, there have been instances where individuals, community groups or armed gangs have denied SPDC access to spill sites.

She said, “SPDC categorically denies these allegations, the JIV team is led by the operating company and includes representatives of the regulatory bodies and the Ministry of Environment.

“Officers of the Nigerian Police Force, the relevant state government personnel and impacted communities also attend.

“Civil society members are invited to join these joint investigation visits as observers to the process.

“Allegations of intimidation or exclusion of community people in JIVs in Ikarama, Biseni or any other areas are untrue and completely baseless. Also, allegations that we withheld JIV reports from people are false.”

However investigations conducted indicated that most spill incidents induced by equipment failures were rarely reported by SPDC on its spill incident website.